Critics have often had reservations with any ghost band touring long after the death of the leader, along with the retirement or death of the musicians that helped make the band famous. But the Count Basie Orchestra has remained active since their leader's death in 1984 for one good reason: the musicians hired to take the place of previous players have been true to the band book while still offering swinging solos. Unlike the
Duke Ellington Orchestra, which was handicapped by the death of the leader (who also served as an arranger and composer who wrote specifically for the strengths of individuals who played with him),
Basie's band relied more on an easygoing swing and less of a personalized sound that could be comprised severely due to someone's departure.
That said, the new edition of the band, led by trombonist
Bill Hughes utilizes both existing band charts and updated treatments of favorites. As a result, this concert recording proves that
Basie's music is not a museum piece to be played with exactness, but with ears open to the future. Most of the repertoire, aside from obvious requests like "One O'Clock Jump" and "Jumpin' at the Woodside," come from the band's repertoire of the '50s and '60s, with a few twists. The lush ballad "We're in Love Again," a feature for baritone saxophonist John Williams, was a rare composition by
Ellington's star baritone saxophonist
Harry Carney. Sadly, the liner notes fail to identify the soloists, though each of the performances is enjoyable. One
Basie veteran who returned to the fold for this concert is drummer
Butch Miles, who appeared on a number of
Basie's recordings in the second half of the '70s. Of all the so-called "ghost" or "tribute" bands active in the 21st century, the Count Basie Orchestra remains on top by a wide margin, with the proof evident on this swinging live CD. ~ Ken Dryden