Seattle's Tooth & Nail has developed a reputation as the home for positive-thinking, hookalicious pop-punk and alternative combos, many sporting fancy haircuts and a Christian-influenced worldview.
Anberlin fits this mold. Led by the soaring, slightly froggy-voiced vocals of
Stephen Christian, the band also includes Joseph Milligan (guitar), Nathan Young (drums), Joey Bruce (guitar), and Deon Rexroat (bass).
Blueprints for the Black Market features 11 songs buffed to a gleaming finish by producer
Aaron Sprinkle, ex of Christian punkers
Poor Old Lu. While it accesses the earnestness of emo through a side door,
Blueprints removes punk and hardcore from the equation entirely. Some songs feature dynamics evocative of these genres ("Naïve Orleans," the post-hardcore stylings of "Glass to the Arson"), but those same tracks are cleaned up with electronic programming or lush chorus vocals that are much closer to bland alternative pop/rock. The bopping "Foreign Language" marries the yearning of
Cutting Crew to a post-new wave beat, but a song later
Anberlin is channeling the grandiose proto-metal of Tool, albeit without that group's slithering underbelly. This obviousness doesn't do
Blueprints for the Black Market any favors. It's such a glimmering recording, and the songs are so minutely arranged to represent a particular sound, that the album ends up becoming an utterly pleasant bore.
Christian and his cohorts turn in some determined performances, but they lack any definition. A preening cover of
the Cure's "Love Song" doesn't help matters. ~ Johnny Loftus