Like so many string quartets, the
Panocha Quartet has its origins as a student ensemble, in this case from the Prague Conservatory. Unlike others, the
Panocha has proven to have some remarkable staying power, having been in existence since 1968. Since its inception, it has distinguished itself as an interpreter of works by Czech composers. The string quartets of Antonin Dvorák are central to the repertoire, and most of these works have been recorded many times by the quartet. This album features two of Dvorák's quartets -- the 10th and 14th -- each of which immediately proceeded two landmarks in Dvorák's output, the 11th and 15th quartets. The 10th and 14th are still masterworks in their own right, but require especially informed, musical performances to truly bring out their qualities. Unlike their recording of the complete Dvorák quartets on the Supraphon label, the present recording on the Camerata label is rather inconsistent and spotty, not delivering everything these two quartets need. The
Panocha Quartet's sound quality vacillates between the deep, warm, and inviting tone characteristic of its Supraphon recording and shrill, almost grating moments. Intonation is also extremely inconsistent, at times becoming so poor as to make listening uncomfortable. Listeners interested in hearing this ensemble perform these works would do well to skip this album and opt for the complete set instead.