A collaboration between fellow fringe dwellers
Daniel Johnston and
Mark Linkous seems like it should be a match made in twisted outsider-pop heaven. After all, the
Sparklehorse leader is obviously a huge fan of
Johnston's volatile but vulnerable music; aside from its influence coloring most of
Sparklehorse's fragile, darkly innocent output,
Linkous has gone as far as to put a cover of
Johnston's "Hey Joe" on his best album,
Good Morning Spider. However, it may be the reverence with which producer/arranger
Linkous treats
Johnston's songs that makes
Fear Yourself such a disappointment: The album has such a clean production that it almost sounds like
Linkous is trying to protect the songs -- or their creator -- from some of their more dangerous or unpredictable impulses. It's also an unusual move, considering that
Linkous is normally a gifted producer who brings an unconventional and sensitive touch to other people's music (most notably
Nina Persson's
A Camp project), and particularly because both
Johnston and
Linkous have the kind of voices and write the kind of songs that work better when they have dusty, subterranean sounds surrounding them. As is evidenced by
Fear Yourself's opening song, "Now," which gradually moves from four-track grit to the rest of the album's sheen à la Dorothy leaving Kansas for Oz, the production is so unnatural that it's almost hard to hear
Johnston's songs. Some of the less-glossy tracks, such as the brooding but optimistic "Must" and the cute "Fish," and more kinetic numbers, like "Mountain Top" and "Love Not Dead," manage to escape the slickly, sickly sweet feeling that plagues most of
Fear Yourself's softer songs (with the notable exception of "Wish"). Both
Fun and
Rejected Unknown prove that
Johnston's strangely beautiful music doesn't have to be recorded on a cassette player to sound authentic, but unfortunately,
Fear Yourself's intricate, careful sound results in a rather bland album.