Zeroing in exclusively on his 1965-69 stint for Immediate Records, this is the best
Chris Farlowe anthology, with 27 songs and 77 minutes of music on a single CD. It was this era that saw
Farlowe's only significant commercial success as a solo act, and the disc includes all half-dozen of his British chart singles (although only one of those, the chart-topping cover of
the Rolling Stones' "Out of Time," was a truly big seller). It also has seven covers of
Mick Jagger-Keith Richard songs (which were produced by
Jagger as well), though all of these were done much better by
the Rolling Stones themselves. To be harsh, as good value (and well-annotated) as this is, 27 songs might be too much for the more casual collector, some of the lesser tracks exposing
Farlowe's weaknesses as a blustery blue-eyed soul singer. There are, however, some decent and overlooked cuts as well, like the original version of "Handbags and Gladrags" (though
Rod Stewart's subsequent cover of the tune would become the definitive one), and the weirdly imaginative sitar-laden arrangement of the jazz standard "Moanin'," which gave
Farlowe a low-charting single. Too, some of the later efforts find
Farlowe toning down his vocal excesses for some uncharacteristically gentle and effective numbers, like "Everyone Makes a Mistake" (which sounds quite a bit like early
Rod Stewart), "Dawn," the folk-rockish "Paperman Fly in the Sky," and "The Last Goodbye" (penned by "Handbags and Gladrags" author
Michael d'Abo). Odder items include "North South East West," co-written by
Farlowe and
Albert Lee, a one-time member of
Farlowe's backing band; the soul ballad "Baby Make It Soon," co-written by Andrew Oldham and future
Alan Parsons Project member
Eric Woolfson; and a bizarre cover of
Bob Dylan's "It's All Over Now, Baby Blue," arranged to sound like (of all things)
the Four Tops' "I Can't Help Myself." ~ Richie Unterberger