After several inconsistent releases, the
Durutti Column hit a purple patch in the mid-'00s. Even the famously self-critical
Vini Reilly recognized this, going so far as to describe
Idiot Savants' predecessor,
Keep Breathing, as one of the only albums in his extensive catalog worthy of a passing grade. With
Idiot Savants, however, the
Durutti Column's run of good form falters slightly, as the album's strengths are marginally outweighed by its weaknesses.
Reilly's music has often integrated sampled vocals, drawing on everything from
Annie Lennox to opera, and that approach is at the heart of this album's standout, the rousing "Better Must Come," which incorporates the refrain from Jamaican child star QQ's hit of the same name. The reason
Reilly first started working with samples was that Tony Wilson (the
Durutti Column's original manager and biggest champion) disliked his protégé's singing; regardless, on "2 Times Nice," another high point,
Reilly turns in a convincing vocal performance, mixing his flat melancholia with unlikely bursts of heavy metal guitar. Elsewhere, he enlists guest singer Poppy Roberts -- most successfully on the delicate "Interleukin 2," a piece composed specifically for Tony Wilson to relax to whilst undergoing cancer treatment. (Wilson himself named the track for one of the drugs he was taking.) These three numbers stretch over six minutes each and are compelling throughout, but a few other lengthy tracks wear out their welcome: "Whisper to the Wind" and "Gathering Dust" soon begin to meander blandly, notwithstanding Roberts' presence, whereas the nine-minute "Please Let Me Sleep" would have been more effective had it ended after the beautiful Spanish guitar passage that occupies the first five minutes. Given the overall inconsistency, this isn't an essential entry in the
Durutti discography; nevertheless, it shows that
Reilly can still come up with fresh, inventive work. Not bad for an artist three decades into his career. ~ Wilson Neate