Theoretically, the pairing of
Jimmy Smith and
Lou Donaldson is a smart idea. Both musicians were instrumental in the development of soul-jazz and were recognized as among the leaders of their genre. Instead of catching fire, however,
Jimmy Smith Trio + LD, falls flat. There are a few moments that fulfill the duo's potential -- both
Smith and
Donaldson trade hot lines on "Star Eyes" -- but in general, the session is bland but pleasant offering nothing truly memorable. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine