What a recital this must have been! Individually, both
Maisky and
Argerich are among the best living players of their instruments:
Maisky is a big-toned, full-blooded cellist and
Argerich is a recklessly impulsive pianist blessed with a flawless technique. Together,
Maisky and
Argerich challenge each other to even higher heights, with
Maisky singing like an operatic baritone and
Argerich taking ever dangerous risks. And in this concert,
Maisky and
Argerich are at the top of their form, delivering performances that are, with one exception, among the most compelling ever recorded. Their
Chopin sonata is far more passionate than any ever recorded:
Maisky's playing makes the venerable
Rostropovich performance seem restrained and
Argerich's playing makes the piano part sound like the dazzling music it is, rather than a demure accompaniment to the cellist. Their Franck sonata has more ardent sensuality than the Act I Love duet from La bohème, with
Maisky making a most convincing case for the work as a cello sonata. Their encore,
Chopin's youthful Polonaise brilliante, succeeds in making the piece sound like more than a virtuoso trifle. Only
Maisky's overly Romantic interpretation of
Debussy's cello sonata is less convincing and, even there, the brilliance of
Argerich's performance cannot be denied. This is as exciting a cello/piano recital as has ever been recorded.