In 2011,
Hootie and the Blowfish are a memory, while
Darius Rucker plays the country circuit, the
Dave Matthews Band has practically evolved into a classic rock act,
Counting Crows are floating about in the ether, and
Matchbox 20 is remembered as the band that spawned
Rob Thomas, but unlike his rootsy compatriots of the mid-to late '90s,
Edwin McCain hasn't changed all that much since
Misguided Roses climbed the charts in 1997. Perhaps he's not selling as many discs or filling the same number of seats, but
Mercy Bound confirms his voice is still in strong shape, he's still writing with his traditional blend of heart, soul, and regular-guy smarts, and his mixture of rootsy light rock, singer/songwriter-inspired folk/ and soaring/ Southern-style melodies is working just as well for him now as ever. With songwriter
Maia Sharp (another veteran of the late-'90s AAA scene) as producer,
Mercy Bound breaks practically no new ground for
McCain, but that isn't necessarily a bad thing; as the last man standing among his graduating class,
McCain sounds determined to carry the flag for a sound he helped define, and he seems perfectly happy to do it. From the romantic introspection of "The Boy Who Cried Love" and "Sober" to the sly, easygoing funk of "Strange Angel" and the folkie storytelling of "Millhouse Girl," this is
Edwin McCain sounding just like
Edwin McCain, unconcerned with musical trends or the whims of the larger audience as he does what feels right. And it's clearly working for him, as this is as well-crafted and impassioned as anything
McCain made during his brief run as a hitmaker, and he and his audience are doubtless happier with this than if he took a stab at Auto-Tuned pop.
Mercy Bound plays to
McCain's strengths, and that should make him and his fans quite happy. ~ Mark Deming