Elvis Costello and
Burt Bacharach first collaborated on "God Give Me Strength," a sweeping ballad that functioned as the centerpiece in Allison Anders' Grace of My Heart. It was a stunning song in the tradition of
Bacharach's classic '60s work and it was successful enough that the composers decided to collaborate on a full album,
Painted from Memory. Wisely, they chose to work within the stylistic parameters of
Bacharach's '60s material, but
Painted from Memory never sounds like a stylistic exercise. Instead, it's a return to form for both artists.
Bacharach hasn't written such graceful, powerful melodies since his glory days, and
Costello hasn't crafted such a fully realized album since
King of America. It's a testament to both that even if the album is clearly in
Bacharach's territory, it feels like a genuine collaboration. Often, the music not only evokes the spirit of
Dionne Warwick, it's reminiscent of Elvis' torching ballads for
Trust.
Costello keeps
Bacharach from his schmaltzier tendencies, and
Bacharach keeps
Costello from overwriting. With its lush arrangements, sighing brass and strings, gentle pianos, and backing vocals, it's clearly a classicist album, yet it sounds utterly timeless. Its melodies are immediate, its emotions subtle, its impact lasting -- and, with that timeless sound,
Painted from Memory illustrates that craft cannot only be its own reward, it can be genuinely moving. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine