Fair or unfair,
Belinda Carlisle's solo recordings were destined to be compared to
the Go-Go's.
Carlisle resented the constant comparisons, but as great an impact as the group had, did she really expect anything different? Understandably, rock critics missed the harder-edged
Carlisle, but in fact, the more polished and slicker one has had her moments.
Runaway Horses,
Carlisle's third solo release, isn't as strong as
Heaven on Earth -- let alone her work with
the Go-Go's -- but is generally likeable and appealing. Although not most critics' cup of tea, the good-spirited, romantic idealism of "Valentine," "Leave a Light On," "Whatever It Takes," and other sugary pop/rock and power pop confections is tough to resist. ~ Alex Henderson