Marion Meadows has the talent and the chops to record a truly great album of improvisatory jazz, be it fusion, post-bop, hard bop, cool jazz, or soul-jazz. The soprano saxophonist did, after all, receive his education in jazz from heavyweights like
Eddie Daniels,
Norman Connors, and the late
Joe Henderson. But regrettably,
Meadows has spent most of his career catering to smooth jazz stations and offering lightweight background music.
Secrets, like so many formulaic smooth sax albums, has a strong
Grover Washington, Jr. influence but generally lacks
Washington's grit, edginess, or sense of adventure. There have been numerous
Washington disciples in smooth jazz (from
Najee to
Dave Koz to
Kenny G to the late
George Howard), and most of them have played it much, much safer than their idol -- which is what
Meadows does most of the time on
Secrets. Overall, this 2009 release is a decidedly conservative affair from
Meadows, who plays mostly soprano sax but gets in some tenor sax and clarinet as well. But
Secrets does have its moments. This CD contains a memorable version of
Pat Metheny's Brazilian-influenced "Here to Stay," and "The Shade Tree" (which is one of
Secrets' vocal offerings) has an appealing,
Michael Franks-ish quality. Also enjoyable is the Latin-tinged "Sand Dancers." So even though
Secrets favors a by-the-book approach most of the time,
Meadows occasionally lets loose and gambles with inspiration. One wishes, however, that he did it a lot more often.
Secrets will probably be well received by the smooth jazz program directors that
Meadows is going after, but he is capable of so much more. ~ Alex Henderson