In melodic death metal and symphonic black metal, the contrast between extreme and non-extreme elements is a lot like the contrast between what jazz musicians call "inside" and "outside" playing. Some avant-garde jazz favors an inside/outside approach; some avant-garde jazz favors outside playing from start to finish -- and similarly, whether a melodic death metal or symphonic black metal album makes greater use of extreme elements or greater use of non-extreme elements depends on the artist.
Skyforger, it turns out, is a melodic death metal album that keeps the extreme elements to a bare minimum and is greatly influenced by progressive metal and power metal as well as folk metal. This late 2008/early 2009 recording isn't just slightly melodic -- it is very melodic -- and while
Skyforger rocks aggressively much of the time, it is never flat-out vicious. Like a lot of melodic death metal albums,
Skyforger offers a contrast between clean vocals and a deep Cookie Monster growl; the Cookie Monster, however, takes a back seat to the clean vocals this time. In fact, extreme elements take such a back seat to non-extreme elements on
Skyforger that some headbangers will wonder if this 47-minute CD should even be called death metal. But then,
Amorphis' willingness to try different things on different albums and their refusal to be pinned down stylistically are among their strong points. Jazz great
Duke Ellington has often been quoted as saying that there are really only two types of music -- good and bad -- and while
Skyforger is hardly ideal from the standpoint of a death metal purist, it is still an excellent metal album. Whether one describes this disc as melodic death metal or as a prog-metal/power metal/folk metal outing with some Cookie Monster growls,
Amorphis should be proud of what they accomplish on
Skyforger. ~ Alex Henderson