Although
Spirit achieved only moderate commercial success in its original configuration from 1968 to 1971, its music turned out to be influential and perennially popular; its last album,
Twelve Dreams of Dr. Sardonicus, went gold six years after it was released. That appeal was reinforced by the success of the individual members. While guitarist
Randy California and
Ed Cassidy continued to lead changing lineups under the
Spirit banner, lead singer
Jay Ferguson and bassist
Mark Andes formed
Jo Jo Gunne, after which
Ferguson went solo and
Andes formed
Firefall, before joining
Heart, and keyboardist
John Locke played with
Hawkwind, among others. Prior commitments as much as anything else kept the original quintet from re-forming in any sustained manner. But
Spirit of '84 (known as The Thirteenth Dream outside the U.S.) was the closest they came, a get-together recorded live in the studio during late 1982 and given major-label release in 1984. Augmented by 13 guest musicians,
Spirit ran through seven of their old numbers and added three new songs. Two of the new ones were written by
Ferguson, and they were more in his solo style (and in the mold of early-'80s synthesizer-heavy pop/rock) than that of the band. Leadoff track "Black Satin Nights," in particular, had the potential to be a hit, had it been released as a single and promoted. In contrast,
California, the other leading songwriter in the band, co-wrote "All Over the World," an overt paean to the '60s peace-and-love worldview. Had the two created an album's worth of material, perhaps with some creative participation from
Locke, the result might have been a collection that at least updated the
Spirit sound for the '80s. As it was, the album was dominated by the remakes, which, not surprisingly, were inferior to the original recordings, but which served to remind listeners how good those recordings had been. The disc concluded with a seven-and-a-half-minute rendition of
Spirit's sole Top 40 hit, "I Got a Line On You," featuring a guitar army that included heavy hitters like
Bob Welch and
Jeff Baxter. It had the feel of a victory lap, but for a band that never quite won the prize in the first place. Not surprisingly,
Spirit of '84 proved to be a one-off reunion, after which the bandmembers went back to their usual occupations. ~ William Ruhlmann