Murder Ballads brought
Nick Cave's morbidity to near-parodic levels, which makes the disarmingly frank and introspective songs of
The Boatman's Call all the more startling. A song cycle equally inspired by
Cave's failed romantic affairs and religious doubts,
The Boatman's Call captures him at his most honest and despairing -- while he retains a fascination for gothic, Biblical imagery, it has little of the grand theatricality and self-conscious poetics that made his albums emotionally distant in the past. This time, there's no posturing, either from
Cave or the Bad Seeds. The music is direct, yet it has many textures, from blues to jazz, which offer a revealing and sympathetic bed for
Cave's best, most affecting songs.
The Boatman's Call is one of his finest albums and arguably the masterpiece he has been promising throughout his career. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine