With the exception of
Stevie Wonder and
Marvin Gaye, one would be hard pressed to name a Motown act who went through as many creative shifts as
the Temptations. While
Wonder's and
Gaye's changes of direction were a product of their own creative rebellion against Berry Gordy's brilliant but often formulaic vision,
the Temptations seemed to be the label's official "keeping up with the times" artists, starting out as interpreters of
Smokey Robinson's silky-smooth sweet soul confections and going on to embrace rock guitars, work with members of
Funkadelic, and be produced by
Rick James, all while holding onto their trademark vocal style. The length and breadth of
the Temptations' career would make it practically impossible for a single-disc career retrospective to be truly comprehensive, and
The Ultimate Collection is missing a few essential tracks (most notably "Psychedelic Shack" and "Runaway Child, Running Wild"), while two latter-day hits, "Treat Her Like a Lady" and "Error of Our Ways," don't exactly bring this set to a triumphant conclusion. But if you're only going to own one
Temptations disc,
The Ultimate Collection is a very good one to get; it includes the majority of the group's biggest hits, the remastering sounds great, and the chronological sequence gives a fine picture of the group's constant musical evolution.
The Ultimate Collection isn't the last word on
the Temptations, but it's a splendid starting point to their music, and will add a satisfying portion of sweet-and-sour soul to your next party. Special added attraction: a rare a cappella take of "My Girl" is included as a bonus. ~ Mark Deming