On albums like
La Isla Bonita and
Breakup Song,
Deerhoof took a back-to-basics approach, concentrating on joyful blasts of noise pop and surprising funk. With
The Magic, they look back even further, borrowing inspiration from the music they loved as children. Given the youthful wonder and spontaneity that drive their music -- no matter how sophisticated their ideas and playing are -- it's an inspired concept. While making the album,
Deerhoof took that spontaneity to extremes: they wrote and recorded most of
The Magic within a week, while the three tracks they submitted to HBO's '70s music industry drama Vinyl were penned over a weekend. Somewhat perversely, these more traditional-sounding rock songs are among
The Magic's freshest moments. It's amusing to hear them impersonate an old-school rock & roll band, but the more closely they imitate rock tropes, the more their quirks stand out, resulting in funhouse mirror versions of punk, glam, and hair metal. "Plastic Thrills" distills rock to a strutting riff and nihilistic lyrics that sound surprising -- and all the more effective -- coming out of
Greg Saunier and
Satomi Matsuzaki's mouths, while
Ed Rodriguez's lead vocal on the brilliant
Stooges caricature "That Ain't No Life to Me" adds to the feeling that this is the work of another band. Later, "Dispossessor" features a truckload of the widdly guitars that
Deerhoof normally put in very different surroundings. As on the
Ramones-inspired
La Isla Bonita,
The Magic finds the band riffing on its own history as much as the rock songbook. "Kafe Mania!" is quintessential
Deerhoof, its outbursts topped by
Matsuzaki's sweetly rhythmic roll call of caffeinated beverages, while "Little Hollywood" recalls
Deerhoof vs. Evil's jittery electro-pop experiments and "Debut" showcases the polyrhythms that became a staple of their music over the years. More often than not, the bandmembers' homages to their childhood favorites end up sounding completely
Deerhoof: with
Matsuzaki on lead vocals, the arena-ready chug of "Acceptance Speech" sounds worlds away from the album's other rock pastiches. On "Life Is Suffering," the band reconfigures soul music, with
Saunier and
Matsuzaki's climbing harmonies making it a standout. While "The Devil and His Anarchic Surrealist Retinue" and "Criminals of the Dream" are prime examples of how easily the band combines wide-ranging sounds into something unique,
The Magic sometimes feels muddled. The woozy cover of
the Ink Spots' "I Don't Want to Set the World on Fire" is strange even by
Deerhoof's standards, if only because it's one of the few times they've ever seemed to be trying too hard. Elsewhere, the noodly "Model Behavior" and the throwaway "Patrasche Come Back" suggest the album could've used some editing (at 51 minutes, it's nearly twice as long as
La Isla Bonita). Even if
The Magic doesn't always hold together, it still delivers moments of pure anarchic fun. [
Magic was also released on LP.] ~ Heather Phares