Writing on the Wall's only album was theatrical heavy blues-psychedelic-rock that, despite its power and menace, was too obviously derivative of better and more original artists to qualify as a notable work. The organ-guitar blends owe much to
the Doors,
Procol Harum, and
Traffic, though the attitude is somehow more sour and ominous than any of those groups. The vocals are sometimes pretty blatant in their homages to
Arthur Brown, particularly when Linnie Paterson climbs to a histrionic scream;
Jim Morrison, Gary Brooker, and
Stevie Winwood obviously left their imprints on him too. Throw in some of the portentous drama from the narrations to the Elektra astrological concept album The Zodiac: Cosmic Sounds (particularly on "Aries") as well. A problem is, however, that not many singers other than
Morrison and
Brown could pull off this kind of solemn poetic mood, and on "Aries," to take one example, the attempt to create a seance-like atmosphere seems faintly ridiculous. To look at the positives, the band does play with a soul-rock crunch; the songs sometimes shift tempo (occasionally in and out of martial beats) and melody unpredictably, if not nearly as memorably as, say,
the Crazy World of Arthur Brown did; and there are occasional off-the-wall touches of accordion and, on "Virginia Waters," speaking-in-tongues vocals with a nod to
Family's
Roger Chapman. The 2007 CD reissue on Ork is an expanded two-CD edition adding lengthy historical liner notes, the non-LP 1969 single "Child on a Crossing"/"Lucifer Corpus," and, on the second disc, a dozen 1968-1971 tracks that weren't released at the time. The second disc thus adds up to an entire second
Writing on the Wall album of sorts, though the material on it is from several sources. This includes a 1968 track, "Felicity Jane," with a lighter psychedelic feel than the heavier rock they were doing by the end of the decade; seven tracks from 1972 whose precise origin isn't specified, though possibly some or much of it's from an unreleased album they recorded that year; a lo-fi 1971 demo of "Buffalo" (a re-recording of which is among the 1972 tracks); a couple songs from 1973 TV appearances; and a cut from an aborted attempt at an album later that same year. While this evaluation seems counter to the opinions of those who were there at the time, who usually regard the late '60s as
Writing on the Wall's peak, the second disc actually comes off better than the material on the first CD, though it's still not remarkable. In part that's because Linnie Paterson isn't the lead singer on most of these. As a possible consequence, the music has less bombast than the 1969 recordings, though it's only acceptably varied early-'70s British hard rock with soul, blues, and progressive elements. ~ Richie Unterberger