Like a female version of
the White Stripes,
the Pack A.D. play a drums 'n' guitar version of the blues that sounds at once minimalist and raucously loud. Mistakes are frequent, riffs are botched, and the percussion is unapologetically messy, which gives this debut a looseness that surprisingly works in its favor. What could otherwise be written off as a mere gimmick ("Hey! Those two girls are playing a predominantly male form of music!") comes across as genuine and heartfelt, taking strength in the tiny flaws that align the album with classic blues records of yesteryear. But while
Tintype is certainly authentic, it isn't always good.
Becky Black's throaty vocals look for some middle ground between
Janis Joplin and
Ann Wilson, and her scratched-to-hell wails are the highlight of the disc. When she drops into a lower register, however,
Black's soulfulness sounds forced, taking much of the swagger out of
the Pack's racket. A duo like this is meant to be heard live, where
Black can push her voice to its scratchy limit and
Maya Miller's percussion can rattle the audience's beer mugs. The studio simply doesn't suit them at this formative stage in their career, and only a small handful of songs -- mostly the three "Hardtrack Saloon" pieces, which sound as though they were recorded at a honky tonk bar during the American West's expansion -- make good use of the recording process. The magic is still there, buried somewhere beneath
Black's sporadic awkwardness and the potentially incendiary sounds of her guitar, but it doesn't quite come alive on this disc. Here's to hoping for a live album sometime soon.