Last time we saw
3 Doors Down it was in 2011, when the post-alt quintet started to take stock of the onset of middle age on the monotone
Time of My Life. Looking straight into the abyss caused the band to fracture, with the group losing founding member guitarist
Matt Roberts and longtime bassist
Todd Harrell, leaving vocalist
Brad Arnold firmly at the helm.
Arnold retained drummer
Greg Upchurch, kicked Chris Henderson up to lead guitar, added new guitarist
Chet Roberts and bassist
Justin Biltonen, then hired renowned heavy rock producer
Matt Wallace to make 2016's
Us and the Night. Despite its nocturnal title,
Us and the Night is by many measures a brighter affair than
Time of My Life: the guitars are still cranked to the max and the rhythms would fill a stadium but the tenor is lighter, the band spending equal time on affirmations ("Everybody's got a right to change," they cry on "Believe It") and sly sleaze ("In the Dark" -- as in "She likes to do it in the dark" -- is
Nickelback by any other name). If
3 Doors Down favor wide strokes over specificity, that only underscores how they're attracted to the elements that drift along in the mainstream current, appropriating shopworn mass culture so they can spin it into something bigger and louder. To their credit, these instincts sound better here than they have on the last couple records because they embrace their essence, how they want to be broader and burlier than the rest. Thankfully, the reconstituted
3 Doors Down have decided to temper this instinct by looking on the sunny side of life on
Us and the Night, a decision that makes this one of their more appealing albums. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine