Somehow it seems fitting that the first AmIdol out of the gates in 2008 is
Kristy Lee Cook, the savvy, purported country singer who sold her horse to get on TV, and then once she was there proceeded to sell out any way she could to stay on the show.
Cook quickly sussed out that in order to stick around she needed to exude a blend of faith, family, and country -- meaning both patriotism and the music -- and sold herself with a tenacity that brought a smile to
Simon Cowell's face.
Kristy Lee may not have gone the distance on Idol but she presented a full, easy-to-package identity to rival
David Cook, and her debut
Why Wait follows through on every promise she made on the show, right down to a horse popping up again on the front cover. Like
Carrie Underwood and
Kellie Pickler before her,
Kristy Lee heads straight into modern country, landing somewhere between her two Idol predecessors, as she sings a crossover country-pop similar to
Carrie with just a bit of down-home spunk from
Kellie. She's not half the diva of
Underwood or the cornball of
Pickler, coming across more like the girl next door made good, and that's pretty endearing on record, especially as she has songs as clever as "15 Minutes of Shame," and as quietly insistent as the AAA-pop of "Hoping to Find" and "Not Tonight," which feel a bit like
Faith Hill at her crossover peak. She also has plenty of songs that pander as boldly as she did on Idol when she sang "God Bless the USA," including a new version of that cheesy chestnut. Defying all expectations, that's not the most shameless thing here, as it's topped by the maternal love letter "Like My Mother Does," a salute so syrupy it borders on camp. But if this and the
Lee Greenwood cover, along with a couple other things here, are what it takes to shore up
Kristy Lee Cook's bona fides as a country singer, so be it: when
Why Wait clicks -- which it does about half the time -- it's really solid, endearing country-pop. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine