Much of the music on this CD from
Duke Ellington's 1958 Paris concerts is familiar to collectors from its appearance on various European bootleg labels, but Pablo does a better job arranging and annotating this music, which was recorded by Radio France with permission. The program mixes favorites such as "Take the 'A' Train" (featuring trumpeter
Ray Nance, who also soloed on its recorded debut), the always exciting medley of "Kinda Dukish" and "Rockin' in Rhythm" (though the first piece is not listed), and the inevitable wailing extended solo by
Paul Gonsalves in "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue." "Juniflip," a fairly new piece written to feature
Clark Terry's matchless flügelhorn, was performed only a handful of times and left the band book with his departure the following year. "Frustration," a complex piece featuring baritone saxophonist Harry Carney, never received proper acclaim, though it clearly is a high point of the concert. Alto sax great
Johnny Hodges is the focal point of "Jeep's Blues," "All of Me," and a blistering "Things Ain't What They Used to Be." While the music is well recorded and swinging, it is not without its blemishes. A rapid-fire take of "Newport Up" finds both clarinetist
Jimmy Hamilton and
Gonsalves having repeated problems with reed squeaks, so it is possible that the bandleader was punishing them for overindulging prior to the set (as he was known to do), but both
Terry and drummer Sam Woodyard save the day.
Hamilton's problems evaporate during the previously unreleased "Tenderly," though W.E. Timmer's excellent
Ellington discography indicates that this track may have come from a concert elsewhere in Paris on the previous night. The excellent liner notes by Paul De Barros are an added bonus to this very rewarding disc. ~ Ken Dryden