Recorded in three sessions between 1988 and 1989 for Virgin Classics,
Melvyn Tan and
Roger Norrington's performances of
Beethoven's five piano concertos produced something of a sensation when they were first issued. Purists who valued the big tone of the modern concert grand and the big sound of the modern symphony orchestra were dismayed at the tinkly tone of
Tan's fortepiano and the scrawny sound of
Norrington's
London Classical Players. But true purists -- those who averred the path to aesthetic truth lay through the use of period instruments and historically informed performance practices -- found
Tan's fortepiano refreshingly subtle and nuanced and
Norrington's orchestra bracingly clear and colorful.
Reissued 20 year later on a Virgin Veritas two-disc set with the Fifth Concerto split between discs,
Tan and
Norrington's
Beethoven concertos no longer sound especially tinkly or scrawny. True,
Tan's lean, light instrument lacks the raw power of a concert grand and
Norrington's clean, bright orchestra lacks the mass and weight of a symphonic orchestra. But for ears grown accustomed to such things after two decades of historically informed performances on period instruments, these are neither negative nor positive qualities, but merely interpretive choices.
Twenty years later, a more important concern for all listeners is the quality of the performances themselves. For some,
Tan's balletic rhythms and acrobatic virtuosity and
Norrington's buoyant tempos and primary colors will prove entirely welcome. For others, the performers' perceived want of gravitas in slow movements and profundity in the later concertos may be off-putting. Captured in close, cool digital sound, it is probably wisest to sample
Tan and
Norrington's performances first.