The first
Mahavishnu Orchestra's original very slim catalog was padded out somewhat by this live album (recorded in New York's Central Park) on which the five jazz/rock virtuosos can be heard stretching out at greater length than in the studio. There are only three selections on the disc, all of which were to have been on the group's then-unissued third album -- two of them, guitarist
John McLaughlin's "Trilogy: Sunlit Path/La Merede la Mer" and keyboardist
Jan Hammer's "Sister Andrea," are proportioned roughly as they were in their studio renditions, while the third,
McLaughlin's "Dream," is stretched to nearly double its 11-minute studio length. Each develops organically through a number of sections, and there are fewer lockstep unison passages than on the earlier recordings.
McLaughlin is as flashy and noisy as ever on double-necked electric guitar, and
Hammer and violinist
Jerry Goodman are a match for him in the speed department, with drummer
Billy Cobham displaying a compelling, raw power and dexterity to his work. Yet for all of the superb playing, one really doesn't hear much music on this album; electricity and competitive empathy are clearly not enough, particularly on the 21-minute "Dream," which left a lot of fans feeling let down at the end of its side-two-filling run. The studio versions of these three pieces, along with other tracks being worked up for their third album, have appeared as
The Lost Trident Sessions -- dating from May and June of 1973 -- thus giving fans a means of comparing this repertory to what the band had worked out (or not worked out) in the studio; and
Between Nothingness and Eternity has come up a bit in estimation as a result, benefiting as it does from the spontaneity and energy of a live performance, though even that can only carry this work so far -- beyond the personality conflicts that broke up the band, they seem to have been approaching, though not quite reaching, a musical dead end as well. ~ Richard S. Ginell & Bruce Eder