Both on his own and with his band
the Heavy Eights,
David Kilgour built up a strong CV of chiming, noisy, and sometimes thickly psychedelic indie rock since
the Clean stopped recording (for a while) in the early '90s. On records like 1994's Sugar Mouth or 2004's
Frozen Orange, right up to 2014's
End Times Undone, he's made thoughtful, tuneful albums that chime warmly as his understated vocals deliver a big, soft punch. It's a formula that has served him well for a long time, but on 2019's
Bobbie's a Girl,
Kilgour and his band change things up. For one thing, it's mostly an instrumental album, with Tony De Raad and
Kilgour's acoustic and electric guitars carrying the main melodic weight, Thomas Bell's bass and Taane Tokona's drums subtly shading the background, and an array of carefully placed keyboards coloring in spaces here and there. A majority of the songs are meditative and inward-looking while still being darkly compelling. "Entrance" sets the scene like a cloud settling in overhead, and many of the songs follow suit. Sprinkled in among the pretty, wordless ballads ("Coming in from Nowhere Now"), dramatic
Bad Seeds-esque laments ("Swan Loop"), and off-kilter noise-blues jams ("Ngapara") are occasional pop songs like the sweetly soaring "Smoke You Right Out of Here" and "Looks Like I’m Running Out," which spits out shards of pain in fragments of electric guitar then attempts to heal the damage with reassuring vibraphone runs. It's no surprise that the album's tone is extra thoughtful and a little sad at times, since it's inspired and shaped by the death of
Kilgour's mother as well as his longtime mate Peter Gutteridge. The band took their time making the music and creating the right feel, and the heartbreaking results show that their efforts were well worth it. Along the way,
Kilgour realized that jettisoning the words allowed the interplay of the instruments to conjure up the exact feeling of loss and melancholy that he was looking for without language getting in the way. That choice makes the album a little less accessible on first listen, but once the music takes hold, it sinks in deeply. Though it is something of an outlier, at its core,
Bobbie's a Girl is just like the other albums
Kilgour has made over his long career: lovely pop music powered by his knack for crafting songs that feel like snippets from real life. ~ Tim Sendra