For those who love the idea of
Guided By Voices a bit more than the reality, it's sometimes hard not to be frustrated with
Robert Pollard, a scattershot genius who is equally well-defined by both halves of that description.
GBV leader
Pollard is a startlingly gifted and prolific songwriter and musician, but he also displays either an inability or a disinterest in separating his wheat from his chaff, as anyone who has tried to plow through his relentless barrage of side projects has doubtless noticed. Which is why
Earthquake Glue is such a pleasant surprise -- it may well be the most consistent and satisfying
Guided By Voices album to date, and if its potent rock crunch is bettered by 2001's superb
Isolation Drills, this comes close enough to make any fan pummel his air guitar with glee. While the sharper focus and tight set list of
Earthquake Glue is impressive, just as important is how good
Guided By Voices sounds as a band these days; while usually regarded as little more than
Pollard's backing group, this edition of
GBV has become tight, emphatic, and joyously powerful after several years on the road and in the studio, with the guitars of
Doug Gillard and Nate Farley and the rhythm section of
Tim Tobias and
Kevin March giving the tunes all the smarts and twice the muscle their creator could have hoped for. And while
Earthquake Glue lacks the clunky lo-fi ambience of
Bee Thousand or
Alien Lanes, these songs suggest
Pollard and his collaborators have been able to take the spontaneity and adventure of those tracks and graft them into a better structured and more satisfying framework. If
Earthquake Glue isn't a masterpiece, it's as close as this band can be expected to get, and is the rare
Guided By Voices effort that's imaginative enough for longtime loyalists and tight enough for dabblers at the same time. ~ Mark Deming