Despite its promise to offer "twisted spins on the fresh hits of the Motor City's mysterious minimalist garage duo
Jack & Meg White,"
Electrostripes: An Electro Tribute to the White Stripes is for the most part disappointingly straightforward, delivering what sounds like robot karaoke versions of songs like "I'm Finding It Harder to be a Gentleman," "Fell in Love With a Girl," and "St. James Infirmary Blues." Come to think of it, robot karaoke sounds pretty appealing, and in some ways the rigid beats, icy synths, and deadpan vocals that dominate this album do have an awkward charm, particularly on Sin>The>Tik's versions of "I Can't Wait" and "Apple Blossom," and Satin and Circuits' "Hotel Yorba." However, considering how well-written and tightly structured
the Stripes' songs are, it's kind of a pity that the artists involved in
Electrostripes didn't go a little further with their electro makeovers of these tracks and do something truly twisted with them. The cybernetic covers of "Hello Operator" and "You're Pretty Good Looking (For a Girl)" -- by Master Control and Commander Xanadu, respectively, although with all the vocoders they sound practically identical -- have the right idea and present a few more tweaks than the majority of the album does, although they could've pushed the envelope (or filter) further as well. Sin>The>Tik's "Dead Leaves and the Dirty Ground" also nearly works, trading the brooding swagger of the original for a more cold-blooded, menacing sound; however, this track -- along with nearly the entire album -- sounds curiously flat, with drums that lack dynamics and arrangements that feature lots of dead air (as opposed to the charged minimalism of
the Stripes' style). Though it was probably conceived as nothing more than a novelty, on which terms it's more or less adequately quirky,
Electrostripes still feels like something of a missed opportunity; with groups such as
Ladytron,
Adult., and
Broadcast emphasizing and experimenting with pop song structures in electronic music (albeit in very different ways), it feels like something similarly unique could be done with
the White Stripes' songs if they were in the right hands. As it stands, however,
Electrostripes: An Electro Tribute to the White Stripes almost justifies
the White Stripes' aversion to most electronic music -- when it's applied to their songs, anyway. ~ Heather Phares