Chvrches' impact on the pop landscape made itself known almost immediately after the release of The Bones of What You Believe -- in the years that followed, artists big and small were borrowing the Scottish trio's flair for heart-on-sleeve lyrics wrapped in soaring, synth-laden choruses. Even if the sensitive synth-pop field was more crowded at the time of
Every Open Eye's release than it was in 2013,
Chvrches distinguish themselves by continuing to do this sound better than just about anyone. Rather than expanding on their debut's combination of hooks and huge soundscapes, they streamline the formula that made songs like "Recover" and "The Mother We Share" so beloved. "Never Ending Circles," with its staccato verses and sweeping choruses, might be the quintessential
Chvrches song. This isn't to say that
Every Open Eye is predictable. The band makes some subtle adjustments, opting for a bright, punchy approach inspired by
Quincy Jones' work with
Michael Jackson on
Off the Wall and
Thriller, where the producer made a handful of elements sound massive. Sometimes the '80s influence is understated, adding a more urgent bounce to songs like "Keep You on My Side" and "Bury It;" sometimes it's more blatant, with the synth tones on "Make Them Gold" evoking the theme song to St. Elmo's Fire, and the giddy arpeggios on "Clearest Blue" echoing
Depeche Mode's "Just Can't Get Enough." But even if
Every Open Eye is cheerier-sounding than The Bones of What You Believe, its emotions are just as complex. As on their debut, it's
Lauren Mayberry who brings
Chvrches' skyward sounds back down to earth. On songs such as "Empty Threat" and "Playing Dead," she's vulnerable yet clear-eyed, open to letting people into her heart and strong enough to let them go if and when the time comes.
Martin Doherty sings one of the album's most disillusioned songs, the
Twin Shadow-esque "High Enough to Carry You Over" and shines on "Down Side of Me," a mournful duet with
Mayberry that delivers one of the album's stand-out moments and proves the band's dark side is alive and well. It's another example of how
Chvrches give fans what they want without rehashing their debut on
Every Open Eye, an almost uncannily well-crafted second album. [An Extended Edition of
Every Open Eye was released in 2016, featuring eight bonus tracks including remixes of "Leave a Trace," "Empty Threat," and "Clearest Blue."] ~ Heather Phares