The Beautiful South modestly inaugurate a new label association with Sony with this all-covers collection. Artists known for original material who make albums like this often do so to pay tribute to the beloved music of their youth; think of
John Lennon's
Rock 'n' Roll or
David Bowie's
Pin Ups.
The Beautiful South, however, are known for their sarcastic lyrics wrapped in pretty melodies and arrangements, and a gaze at the track list inevitably poses the question whether the band's sense of irony has crept into its song choices. Is this really music that they love, or are they taking the piss? The latter seems to be the case at the top, a version of "You're the One That I Want" from the movie adaptation of Grease, transformed from the driving rocker wailed by
John Travolta and
Olivia Newton-John into a dramatic ballad sung with what sounds like mock sincerity. Much the same can be said of the loping, country-styled arrangement of
ELO's "Livin' Thing" that follows. Clearly, whether they mean these performances affectionately or comically, the members of the Beautiful South are intent on redefining the songs by giving them arrangements their creators never would have dreamed of. It may be that, the fruitier the selection, the more they feel the need to transform it.
Willie Nelson's "Valentine,"
Rufus Wainwright's "Rebel Prince," and especially
the Stylistics' "I'm Stone in Love with You" are not messed about with very much. But
Blue Öyster Cult's "Don't Fear the Reaper" gets a Latin arrangement, and
the Ramones' "Blitzkrieg Bop" is rendered in much the way
Buddy Holly & the Crickets might have done, if they'd been trying to transform it into "Peggy Sue." Whether the Beautiful South are serious or presenting this music largely tongue in cheek, however, they succeed in giving the listener new ways to hear familiar songs, some of which always seemed like guilty pleasures at best. Who knew that TV pop group
S Club 7's "Don't Stop Moving" was a halfway decent song? ~ William Ruhlmann