Although it occasionally sounds a little ordinary,
Athenaeum's debut album is an appealing collection of jangly, melodic post-grunge that draws equally from
R.E.M. and its offspring. The songs may be a little uneven, but when they get their hooks together, as on the single "What I Didn't Know," the group has a ragged, catchy charm that bodes well for their future. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine