One of the most winning qualities about
Justin Townes Earle's music has been its modesty; his best work is dominated by an easy, unforced groove that's part Memphis and part Nashville, and the music doesn't get in the way of the lyrics but glides side by side with a subtle insistence. While
Earle generated a cool Stax-gone-acoustic sound on 2012's
Nothing's Gonna Change the Way You Feel About Me Now, 2014's
Single Mothers eases back into a spectral, middle-of-the-night sound, with
Earle backed by a low-key three-piece band and the pedal steel guitar adding a mournful tone to most of these songs of lonely lives and broken hearts. (The simple approach matches the album's brevity, which comes in a mere 30 minutes.) The spare, often stark surfaces of the arrangements and production on
Single Mothers make a set of sad songs sound all the more downbeat, and
Earle's reputation for hurtin' songs isn't about to change when folks hear this album; "Picture in a Drawer" and "White Gardenias" are abject tales of romantic rejection, "My Baby Drives" is a witty number with a painful subtext, "Worried Bout the Weather" uses an oncoming storm as a striking metaphor for unrequited love, and the title track about busted marriages and the emotional toll on everyone involved is all the more difficult to hear when one knows how much it mirrors
Earle's own life experiences. There are moments where
Single Mothers feels like art therapy as much as music, but this album communicates its pain with intelligence and a gentle touch, and as a singer and lyricist
Earle grows with each album; there are more than a few moments of brilliance on this set if you don't mind sharing a rough and lonesome road with
Earle for a while. ~ Mark Deming