While the
Rosamunde Trio itself has only been in existence since 2002, its members have more than two decades of chamber music experience in other combinations. The result is a very refined, polished ensemble whose years of experience come across in its unified musical vision in this recording of the
Tchaikovsky and
Shostakovich second piano trios. The
Tchaikovsky Trio, which has the ability to get bogged down because of its length, is fresh and engaging. Its frequent use of octaves between the string instruments poses no difficulty in the intonation department as it does in so many other recordings. There are times when listeners might wish that the members of the
Rosamunde Trio would play with a little more edge and aggression, as even powerful chords and accents are generally legato, but this softer approach is a small price to pay for an otherwise successful interpretation. The
Shostakovich Second Trio is equally well performed. The opening of the first movement is simply haunting, and the ensemble achieves a true feeling of isolation and despondency. The second movement finds the edge that was sometimes missing in the
Tchaikovsky, and the brisk movement is tossed off with incredible speed and accuracy. The highlight, however, is the beautifully maudlin and forlorn third movement. Altogether, this album is a good choice for listeners looking for good introductory recordings for these two cornerstones of the literature.