India.Arie cited creative pressures as one factor in the gap between
Testimony: Vol. 1, Life & Relationship, her last album for Motown, and
Testimony: Vol. 2, Love & Politics, her debut for Universal Republic. Motown possibly was not content enough to yield to the instincts of an artist with three consecutive Top Ten albums and a pair of Grammy awards (to go with 14 additional nominations).
Testimony: Vol. 2 is, if anything, merely a moderate progression from
Testimony: Vol. 1, not sounding anything like a severe turn from
Arie's past. However, the variety of guest collaborators naturally signals and fosters her most eclectic, hardest-to-pigeonhole set yet; in addition to
Musiq (Soulchild) and
MC Lyte, reggae artist Gramps Morgan, Turkish star
Sezen Aksu, and African vocalist
Dobet Gnahore (present on a cover of
Sade's "Pearls") are featured. Regardless of the non-standard inspirations and unexpected guests,
Arie could perform every one of these songs live with just her guitar and not risk shortchanging her audience. Given the new wrinkles, it's not startling that her outlook here has a wider scope, her viewpoint wiser and more outward looking than before, exemplified most through "Ghetto" -- which seems to take cues from
War's "The World Is a Ghetto," building off the notion of people all around the planet facing the same plight -- and the slow, bluesy stomp of the firmly U.S.-centric "Better Way" (featuring
Keb' Mo' on guitar). The tone of the relationship songs is more upbeat, and even occasionally lighthearted, relative to those of
Testimony: Vol. 1, adding a pleasant contrast to the more serious material. If her former label could accuse her of anything, it's that she did not deliver a big single (she does not have a single Top 40 hit), and that's something that won't likely change anytime soon. Her fanbase, big enough to grant
Arie gold sales, will gladly take a fourth steady and honest album over a big pop hit. ~ Andy Kellman