After the various side projects and explorations the band got up to for most of the early '80s, not to mention switching some members around (with bassist
Sauter and drummer
Demeski now forming the rhythm section),
the Feelies made a fine return with
The Good Earth. With co-production from noted fan
Peter Buck, the group exchanged some of the understated tense frazzle of
Crazy Rhythms for a gentler propulsion without losing its trancy edge. Compared to the wispy jangle rock that passed for much of college radio at the time,
the Feelies proposed a different path with the songs' steady pace and murkier feeling.
Demeski's a more than fine replacement for
Fier (his martial playing on "Tomorrow Today" is one of his many entertaining touches),
Sauter's playing emphasizes controlled understatement, and the
Million/
Mercer guitar duo still nails it. The brisker jauntiness of songs like "The Last Roundup," which wears just enough of a country & western edge without seeming like a parody or half-assed, varies the calmer moods elsewhere very well. At the album's considerable best, such as the brief but really lovely acoustic/electric blend of "When Company Comes" or the title track, with an almost epic ending,
Million and
Mercer sound like they inhabit the same body playing two guitars, everything's that much in lovely sync. Their vocals ride low in the mix this time out, but thankfully the sometimes all-too-obvious hints of
Lou Reed in
Mercer's style have been replaced with a more unique, stronger edge -- not that the connection still isn't there on a track like the building groove of "Slipping (Into Something)."
Reed would also love its concluding guitar solo! Perhaps the only criticism is a slight sameness between a few songs, but there's more sly variety on display to offset this gentle treasure. [The 2009 reissue of the album adds three bonus tracks available as digital downloads. These tracks are covers of the Beatles' "She Said, She Said"and Neil Young's "Sedan Delivery" plus a live version of "Slipping (Into Something)"]