This is a really cool mid-price collection, the first of two assembling all of the
Goodman band's work with
Harry James. There are 21 tracks, covering a 13-month period that saw the
Goodman band at the peak of its personnel and popularity, every day breaking new ground for swing even as that music had already swept the country. And, as
Loren Schoenberg points out in his superb notes, with
Harry James in the lineup, the band had a trumpet man who could match
Goodman himself, plus a drummer in
Gene Krupa who kept the rhythm section tight. Most of this material ("Sing Sing Sing," etc.) has been out before somewhere, although it's been very carefully remastered here using the CEDAR system, placing it a cut above other reissues for sound quality. Additionally, there are three distinctly different, newly discovered outtakes of "Camel Hop" and "One O'Clock Jump," plus alternate takes on "Life Goes to a Party" and "Don't Be That Way." One couldn't pick better tracks to have become available in variant forms, representing the
Goodman band at its most accessible and swinging. ~ Bruce Eder