The first album to use this title is one of the most mysterious in
Paul Simon's output and almost belongs more with
Simon & Garfunkel's discography, given its 1965 recording date. Following the failure of
Simon & Garfunkel's first, all-acoustic folk revival-style album,
Wednesday Morning, 3 AM,
Simon headed off to England to see about pursuing music over there. While he was in London, he found himself in demand as a visiting American "folksinger" (though
Simon's credentials in this area were rather limited), began building up a following in the coffeehouses, and was eventually pegged for a performing spot on the BBC. Suddenly, there were requests for
Paul Simon recordings, of which there were none -- as a result of his being signed to Columbia Records in America, however, he was brought into the London studios of British CBS and recorded this album with only his acoustic guitar for backup. The resulting album is spare, almost minimalist, as
Simon runs through raw and unaffected versions of songs that he was known for in London, including "The Sounds of Silence," "The Sun Is Burning," "I Am a Rock," "A Simple Desultory Philippic" (in its earliest form, and far nastier than the version later done by
Simon & Garfunkel), and "Kathy's Song." The notes are very, very strange, but a bigger problem is the production by
Reginald Warburton and Stanley West, which isn't terribly sympathetic; the sound isn't very natural, being very close and booming, but the album is a fascinating artifact of
Simon's work during the interregnum in
Simon & Garfunkel's career. And there is one fascinating number here, "The Side of a Hill," which eventually resurfaced as the countermelody song in the
Simon & Garfunkel version of "Scarborough Fair" (a song curious by its absence here, considering that
Simon was doing it in his coffeehouse appearances) two years later. [
The Paul Simon Songbook was suppressed for decades -- he reportedly objected when Columbia Records began importing it directly during the late '70s, and he never let it be reissued on compact disc until the spring of 2004, when it suddenly appeared as released from Columbia/Legacy, complete with two bonus tracks: alternate versions of "I Am a Rock" and "A Church Is Burning."] ~ Bruce Eder