One of the funniest jokes that has made the rounds in the jazz world goes like this: how many jazz vocalists does it take to sing "My Funny Valentine"? All of them. The point is that so many jazz artists -- males and females, singers and instrumentalists -- insist on performing the most overdone Tin Pan Alley warhorses no matter how much those warhorses been beaten to death over the years, and God forbid they should try to find the jazz potential in rock or R&B songs. Thus, it is refreshing to hear Boston-based vocalist
Cassandre McKinley providing this jazz-friendly tribute to
Marvin Gaye.
Til Tomorrow: Remembering Marvin Gaye is not straight-ahead jazz; what
McKinley does on this 59-minute CD is best described as a mixture of jazz, R&B, and pop (with blues and gospel elements at times). But jazz is certainly an important part of the equation, and
McKinley doesn't simply offer note-for-note covers of songs that the late soul icon recorded; she interprets them, offering plenty of delightful surprises along the way. "I Want You" and "After the Dance" receive bossa nova makeovers, and
McKinley puts a post-bop spin on "Trouble Man" without sacrificing any of the song's bluesiness. "Let's Get It On" becomes surprisingly understated and torch-like in
McKinley's hands, while "I Wish It Would Rain" (a gem associated with
the Temptations and
Gladys Knight & the Pips more than
Gaye, although he recorded it in 1970) is given an appealingly bluesy, folkish spin along the lines of
Tracy Chapman. "I Wish It Would Rain" is one of the disc's least jazz-minded performances, but again,
McKinley never claimed that
Til Tomorrow was the work of a jazz purist. It is, however, an excellent example of a jazz-friendly vocalist acknowledging that great popular music didn't end with Tin Pan Alley. ~ Alex Henderson