Since
American Fool illustrated that
John Cougar was becoming an actual songwriter, it's only proper that he reclaimed his actual last name,
Mellencamp, for the follow-up,
Uh-Huh. After all, now that he had success, he wanted to be taken seriously, and
Uh-Huh reflects that in its portraits of brokenhearted life in the Midwest and its rumbling undercurrent of despair. Although his lyrics still have the tendency to be a little too vague, they are more effective here than ever before, as is his music; he might not have changed his style at all -- it's still a fusion of
the Stones and
Springsteen -- except that he now knows how to make it his own.
Uh-Huh runs out of steam toward the end, but the first half -- with the dynamic rocker "Crumblin' Down," his best protest song, "Pink Houses," the punky "Authority Song," the melancholy "Warmer Place to Sleep," and the garage rocker "Play Guitar" -- makes the record his first terrific album. [Universal's 2005 CD reissue appends a bonus track, an acoustic version of "Pink Houses."] ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine