Edinburgh-based indie rockers the
Broken Records' penchant for arena-sized anthems peppered with violin, cello, and accordion caused U.K. music behemoth NME to dub them the "Scottish
Arcade Fire," a notion that holds more than a little weight upon digging into their bigger-than-life 2009 debut,
Until the Earth Begins to Part. Like their American counterparts, the band sports an enigmatic front man (Jamie Sutherland) with a voice that is as unhinged as it is passionate (his throaty brogue casts a smoky
Heart of Saturday Night-era
Tom Waits/
Darkness on the Edge of Town-era
Bruce Springsteen pallor to the whole affair), a love for all things orchestral, and an unhealthy obsession with semi-apocalyptic, social melodrama, but while the comparison is apt, the
Broken Records have more in common with early, "Big Music" -era
Waterboys. Like Mike Scott, Spencer Chamberlain doesn't wear his heart on his sleeve, he's barely holding on to it with his fingertips. He's looking to connect, and on stand-out cuts like "Nearly Home," " Thoughts on a Picture (In a Paper, January 2009)," and "Slow Parade," he lands a knockout blow, but more times than not, that conviction is nullified by long bouts of midtempo balladry and a sense that all of these songs would sound far more grandiose in a live setting. As far as debut albums go,
Until the Earth Begins to Part may not be as important as it thinks it is, but it certainly delivers the promise of greatness. ~ James Christopher Monger