Even if it's somewhat surprising for
the Flaming Lips to record an album of
Nick Cave covers with a previously unknown 14-year-old singer/songwriter, it's not entirely without precedent. After all,
the Lips have reinterpreted albums by
the Beatles and
Pink Floyd with flair, and their work with
Kesha and
Miley Cyrus shows their willingness to take young female artists seriously. In particular, their work with
Cyrus revealed how striking the combination of a young woman's voice with their layered psych-pop could be, and it's a blend they take to new levels on
Where the Viaduct Looms. After meeting young Canadian superfan
Nell Smith at a 2018 show in Calgary,
Flaming Lips frontman
Wayne Coyne ultimately arranged for
Smith and the band to collaborate on a selection of
Nick Cave songs, figuring that her lack of knowledge about
Cave's music would lend a fresh perspective to their renditions.
Smith's soft-spoken soprano could hardly be more different than
Cave's craggy, powerfully enunciated baritone, and her guileless vocals are the bridge between his dark and deeply felt lyrics and the band's ornate sounds.
Where the Viaduct Looms shares some of
Oczy Mlody's desolate sweetness, particularly on "The Ship Song"'s blissful electronic haze.
The Lips seize every opportunity to re-create
Cave's songs with adventurous production, transforming the hymn-like "Into My Arms" into a lush track worthy of a futuristic
Phil Spector. And, as
Coyne had hoped,
Smith's vocals help push
Viaduct's songs further into new territory. At times, the distance between her youthful tone and the world-weary lyrics almost sounds like she's singing in a foreign language.
Smith and
the Lips use that gap brilliantly on the album's most poignant moments. Their version of "Girl in Amber" -- which
Cave himself praised -- distances itself from the lifetime of mourning he poured into the Skeleton Tree track, resulting in a lighter yet spookier reading that's just as powerful in its own way. Since
Cave and
the Flaming Lips both know a thing or two about trying to encompass the enormity of mortality and loss in their own very different styles, it's not surprising that the simple, haunting versions of "Weeping Song" and "We Know Who You Are" are also among the album's standouts.
Where the Viaduct Looms is a daring and mostly rewarding undertaking, especially for
Smith. Performing the songs of one of alternative music's most acclaimed acts with another backing her, she uncovers meanings and feelings that weren't fully present in the original material -- and that bodes well for what she might be capable of with her own songs. ~ Heather Phares