Jazz musicians have provided so many
Duke Ellington and
Billy Strayhorn tributes over the years that in the late '90s, one greeted an
Ellington/
Strayhorn homage with the question"Do we really need yet another one?" The frustrating thing was how safe many of those tributes continued to be -- instead of taking chances and turning their attention to some of
Ellington and
Strayhorn's lesser-known works, many players chose only the most obvious standards. That's exactly what
Tommy Smith does on
The Sound of Love, a relaxed
Ellington/
Strayhorn tribute that unites him with pianist
Kenny Barron, bassist
Peter Washington, and drummer
Billy Drummond. It's frustrating that the Scottish tenor saxman doesn't surprise us more and that he pretty much sticks to often-recorded classics like "Solitude," "In a Sentimental Mood," and "Chelsea Bridge." This isn't to say that well-known standards should have been off limits, but how about surprising listeners by embracing some of
Ellington and
Strayhorn's lesser-known ballads as well? Heaven knows, one could go on and on about all the gems they wrote that were never as famous as "Prelude to a Kiss" or "Sophisticated Lady." Interestingly,
Smith's most adventurous choice isn't by
Ellington or
Strayhorn -- it's the very
Ellingtonian Charles Mingus piece "Duke Ellington's Sound of Love." But while this album could have taken more chances, it's certainly enjoyable. A 30-year-old
Smith plays with plenty of soul throughout the CD, and the captivating
Barron does the same. Emphasizing ballads,
Sound of Love essentially functions as mood music -- seductive, evocative, lower-the-lights mood music.
Smith is playing it safe this time, but he's also playing from the heart. ~ Alex Henderson